Home
Blog of Updates
Big Island News
Coffee to Spirulina
Free Hawaii
Island Music
Beaches
Volcanoes
Fishing
Vacations
Hilo
Kona
Big Island Maps
 Opportunities
Accommodations
Upcoming Events
Health and Beauty
Restaurant Guide
Contact Us
Big Island E-Zines
 

Big Island Alert: Department of Agriculture Plans to Introduce New Insect Species to Big Island Forests

by Danya Nelson
(Puna)

Affected Guava

Affected Guava

ALOHA!! Big Island Alert!!!

I just found out that the Department of Agriculture has a plan to introduce an alien insect species to implement eradication of strawberry Guava trees.

DEADLINE FOR COMMENTS IS MAY 23.

U.S. Forestry agents plan to introduce a tiny, plant sucking insect from Brazil, into Native Forests on the Big Island this Summer.

Later they plan to introduce this new species of insect to all the Hawaiian Islands. This bug supposedly targets only Strawberry Guava trees, and forms galls on their leaves, and slows fruit production.

I know that the Strawberry Guava is pretty invasive, and I've lived in a "waiwi" forest that was thick, but I love to eat their fruit which is high in vitamin C.

This plan will affect the forest and all it's inhabitants. When you introduce a new species to a habitat, the whole habitat is affected, not just one tree!

First of all I want to find out more about this insect that causes galls on the leaves and reduces the plant's fruit production.

Next what will the lack of guava fruit have on our wild pigs, our birds, and our native forests.

It's hard to believe it would only attack the strawberry guava, and not the many other guava species we have, or even native trees.

Below are excerpts from the environmental assessment draft:

Field release of Tectococcus ovatus (Homoptera: Eriococcidae)
for biological control of strawberry guava,
Psidium cattleianum Sabine (Myrtaceae), in Hawai段
Draft Environmental Assessment
March 2008

Proposed Action: The USDA Forest Service Institute of Pacific Islands Forestry proposes field release in Hawai段 of Tectococcus ovatus Hempel (Homoptera: Eriococcidae) for classical biological control of strawberry guava, Psidium cattleianum Sabine (Myrtaceae), under permits from the Hawai段 Department of Agriculture, Hawai段 Department of Land and Natural Resources, and USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service.
Type of statement: Draft Environmental Assessment


For further information:
M. Tracy Johnson, Ph.D.
Institute of Pacific Islands Forestry
USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station
P.O. Box 236
Volcano, Hawaii 96785
tel: 808-967-7122
fax: 808-933-8120
email: tracyjohnson@fs.fed.us

Summary
The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), Forest Service, Institute of Pacific Islands Forestry, in collaboration with the Hawai段 Department of Agriculture and Hawai段 Department of Land and Natural Resources, proposes the environmental release in Hawai段 of a scale insect from Brazil, Tectococcus ovatus Hempel (Homoptera: Eriococcidae), for classical biological control of strawberry guava, Psidium cattleianum Sabine (Myrtaceae).

Tectococcus ovatus is a highly specific insect that produces leaf galls on strawberry guava in its native range in Brazil. The purpose of establishing this insect species in Hawai段 is to reduce growth and reproduction of strawberry guava, thereby limiting this weed痴 ability to invade native forests and reducing an important source of agricultural pest fruit flies.

Initial release of the biocontrol agent is proposed for the Ola誕 Forest Reserve on the island of Hawai段, however the eventual impact of this agent is expected to extend statewide following redistribution of the agent by state and federal agencies.

Conditions for environmental release of Tectococcus ovatus in Hawai段 have been established by the Hawai段 Department of Agriculture following review and approval by the Hawai段 Board of Agriculture in consultation with the Advisory Subcommittee on Entomology and Advisory Committee on Plants and Animals.

The proposed action requires Plant Protection and Quarantine permits from the USDA, Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS); a permit for import and liberation of restricted organisms from the Hawai段 Department of Agriculture, Plant Quarantine Branch; and a special use permit from the Hawai段 Department of Land and Natural Resources, Division of Forestry and Wildlife.

Spread of the insect from the initial release site will occur naturally via wind dispersal and artificially via redistribution efforts by state and federal agencies involved in strawberry guava management.

Tectococcus ovatus is expected to cause reduced vegetative growth and reduced fruit and seed production, decreasing the spread of strawberry guava over a period of years.

Impacts of Tectococcus ovatus on strawberry guava are expected to have major economic benefits including improved control of pest fruit flies, increased effectiveness of mechanical and herbicidal control, and long-term protection of vulnerable native forest ecosystems from one of their most serious threats.

Impacts on native Hawaiian species, including many endangered rainforest species, are expected to be highly beneficial due to significant reduction in the threat of strawberry guava to native forests in Hawai段.

Proposed site for initial release of Tectococcus ovatus is in the Ola誕 Forest Reserve on the island of Hawai段 (TMK 3-1-9-001-004), however the eventual impact of this agent is expected to extend statewide.

Redistribution of the agent to additional sites on Hawai段 and other islands will be conducted by state and federal agencies with responsibilities for managing strawberry guava.

email comments to tracyjohnson@fs.fed.us

with a copy to oeqc@doh.hawaii.gov and

savetheguava@gmail.com

call the USDA FS at(808)967-7122

for more info. contact SAVE THE GUAVA at (808)935-5563

or check out this article

http://hunterbishop.com/journal/2008/5/16/weed-biocontrol-plan-unconvincing.html?lastPage=true&postSubmitted=true

For the Full Environmental Draft click here

DEADLINE FOR COMMENTS IS MAY 23.

Comments for
Big Island Alert: Department of Agriculture Plans to Introduce New Insect Species to Big Island Forests

Click here to add your own comments

Oct 18, 2008
New Plan of Attack
by: Syd SInger

Aloha Friends of the Strawberry Guava (and opponents of the scale insect from Brazil),

The County Council is holding a propaganda meeting on October 21 in Kona, at 6:30 PM, to convince us all that the insect should be released and we should all say goodbye to our strawberry guava. The meeting will begin with 4 presentations by various government related anti-guava/pro-insect groups. They refuse to give us a chance to present our side. Clearly, they are afraid to allow the opposition a voice. After these lengthy presentations, we would be allowed 2 questions addressed to the panel. At the end there will be 2 minutes of testimony allowed. There will probably again be dozens of government stooges waiting to testify and take up time, wearing us down until people just leave out of disgust and fatigue, as happened at the last meeting. Realize that the resolution the council is considering is against the insect release, yet the only presentations are from those in favor of the release. This is clearly a corrupted process.

I feel we should not attend this meeting! It is unfair, one-sided, and will not help our cause. In addition, there is no reason for this meeting, since there is no new information released by Tracy Johnson of the Forest Service. He is supposed to release a revised environmental assessment (EA), which should address the concerns already expressed by the public. Until we see his new EA, there is nothing new to discuss at the county council.

However, we must show that we still care about this issue. Instead of wasting our time going to this insect sales pitch, please write to each Council member, and tell them you oppose the release of this insect to attack strawberry guava. Tell them you are boycotting the meeting because it is one-sided, unfair, and should have equal time for presentations by those opposing the insect release. And let them know that we want our waiawi, especially now when feeding our families is a real concern. And we don't want another invasive insect in Hawaii. You might also suggest that they wait until the new EA is released so new information can be addressed. Otherwise, this will be a repeat of the last council meeting, which went on for over 9 hours!

Here are the email addresses of all the County Council members:
http://www.co.hawaii.hi.us/council/contact_council.htm

Thank you for your help with this. We do not need to be at the meeting to let them know we are against the insect release. Please write all the council members right away. Thanks. -- Syd

P.S. Get more petitions signed. We will use them for the comment period for the EA. Download the petition at www.SaveTheGuava.com .


Oct 13, 2008
Meeting in Kona
by: Anonymous

6:30 p.m. PWIRC Special Meeting at Sheraton Keauhou Bay Resort and Spa.

Resolution 718-08 (Comm. 1368) which requests State Dept. of Agriculture to cancel proposed release of a scale insect to control the strawberry guava

Aug 05, 2008
Resolution to oppose the release of the scale insect to attack the strawberry guava.
by: syd singer

Aloha,
Good news! The Hawaii County Council will be considering a Resolution to oppose the release of the scale insect to attack the strawberry guava. We need you to come to voice your opinion and give testimony against this insect attack.
Where: County Council Chambers (For Hilo side, Ben Franklin building, 2nd Floor, 333 Kilauea, Hilo.)
When: Tuesday, August 12, 1PM (Be there at 12:45 to sign up to testify. Testimony will be taken at the beginning of the meeting.)
You will be allowed 3-4 minutes to speak, so be prepared. You may want to write down your thoughts and read them. About 600-800 words will take up the time.
We need you there to show support for this anti-insect resolution! Please make it. Call me at 935-5563 for more info. Those nearer to Waimea or Kona can attend the County Council meeting at these satellite offices. I'll be in Hilo.
There is a whole page on this site with the resolution attached. Thanks -- Syd

Jul 18, 2008
The forest was here before all of us
by: Hamkua Resident

Hello, why bother the forest! Let mother nature take it's course. What going happen when the trees all die? You say going cut back on bearing fruit, not kill the plants. How do you know this? Did you test it? If you have know this for sure, then you have already released it into our forest. Hello! if was not for the forest, we would go hungry. Look when the plantation closed. How do yoy think we ate? feed our children?, We went to the forest and caught pigs. These pigs are all organic, if you really think about it. They eat all natural things in the forest. Sorry that they have to go into private property to find food to eat, but they have been doing it before we all came along. Come on now, we don't need any more bugs here. Leave the forest alone. we need the guavas to feed the animals, so we can have a healther life style.

Jul 01, 2008
Rally
by: Anonymous

ALOHA,
WE ARE EXCITED TO ANNOUNCE THAT THERE WILL BE A RALLY ON THURSDAY, JULY 3, AT 11:00 , AT THE DLNR BUILDING AT 19E. KAWILI STREET IN HILO TO SUPPORT THE STRAWBERRY GUAVA AND OPPOSE THE INSECT RELEASE.

PLEASE GO TO OUR NEW WEBSITE WWW.SAVETHEGUAVA.COM FOR DETAILS. OR CALL THE RALLY ORGANIZER AT 938-8851.

WE NEED TO SEE YOUR THERE!!! PLEASE COME AND SHOW YOUR SUPPORT.

Jun 25, 2008
WHY? What are you thinking?
by: Anonymous

Why introduce this insect? Who will it Benefit? Who pays for this project? If I have a crop of waiwii and it haults to produce fruit because of this program, who do I sue because I cannot provide Tex Drive Inn the supply they demand for there Malasada filling? Part of my Livelihood? You bet! You guys are stupid! I'll bet the Sierra club is behind this!

Jun 08, 2008
learn from the past
by: UH Biology grad

Remember when the mongoose was introduced to kill rats? Then we found out that one was nocturnal and the other was active in the day.

Another example is Euglandina rosea, a cannibal snail that was introduced to kill the African snail.. E. rosea is now currently eatting our endangered Hawaiian tree snails (Achatinella sp.)!!

After a century of introducing alien species to Hawaii for one reason or another.. haven't we learned? Just like there are pro's for this insect, there are con's as well.

Jun 03, 2008
Public Information Meeting on proposed biocontrol of strawberry guava Thurs June 5
by: Tracy Johnson

Aloha,

There will be a public information meeting regarding strawberry guava and the proposed release of the bio-control agent on Thursday, June 5. The meeting will be from 6 to 8 p.m., on the University of Hawaii, Hilo Campus, UCB 127 (Newer building mauka of the main parking lots off Kawili St.,Campus Center and Library.)

Hawaii State Representative Clift Tsuji will moderate the meeting, which will include participants from the Forest Service and other federal and state agencies. The meeting will include a period for questions and answers.

Tracy Johnson
Research Entomologist
Institute of Pacific Islands Forestry
Pacific Southwest Research Station
USDA Forest Service
P.O. Box 236
Volcano, Hawaii 96785
tel: 808-967-7122 fax: 808-967-7158
email: tracyjohnson@fs.fed.us

May 20, 2008
necessary to save the native forest
by: Anonymous

I am a biology student at UH Hilo, and I think from reading these and other comments that people don't know how big a problem SG is in the native forest. Everyone is just concerned about their own plants in their backyard, but they don't realize that SG is out of control and taking over huge sections of native forest, and years (and millions$$) spent hand clearing, pesticides, etc. have not been able to stop it.

Its great that people are paying attention but there are answers to a lot of the concerns if you read up on it. this bug was tested VERY rigorously for years both in Brazil and here in HI before it was even considered for release. the scientists are trying to SAVE the ohia forest, not risk it!

As far as agriculture, the USDA is the lead agency, if this wasn't extensively tested against crop plants and other fruit trees I doubt there's any way they would let it pass (ag is their agenda).

In fact I think its the fact that SG spreads the damaging fruit flies that got them interested in the 1st place. the native birds do not use the fruit as a food source, they prefer the native plants w/ which they have co-evolved. the introduced birds DO use the fruit, but shouldn't we be more concerned about keeping our native forests intacts for the native birds to feed on the native plants? Sorry, that's just my perspective as someone who is passionate about the forests here.

I do sympathize w/ people who use it as a food source, i guess it's asking a sacrifice from them which is hard for anyone, especially food (&right now!) anyway thats my thoughts, lastly i looked up bio-controls for the state of HI -people don't realize this actually goes on all the time, over 254 bio-controls were released 1890-1988, and 210 were successful. 45 achieved COMPLETE control of their target (including 7 weed species). Only 33 (of 254) were found to eventually eat native species (and not necessarily at problem levels), but those were introduced early, before the testing requirements that they have in place now. also, someone mentioned that the public should have a chance to comment, they do! There is an environmental draft going thru the state right now and anyone can comment on it.

OK, aloha to all (waiawi lovers & haters alike!)

May 19, 2008
is there a petition
by: wynema

how can the state justify this without a vote or imput from the taxpayers? this is just wrong. we should be able to have a say in what happens to our community and put this to a vote. I dont know of anyone who thinks this is a good idea. whats wrong with the people making such decisions. the guava still has to be removed manually, so whats the point. dont we have a choice anymore. i like the fruit and am not to lazy to keep the overgrowth cut back.

May 19, 2008
Strawberry Guava is Food!
by: Anonymous

Why eradicate food? My relatives make guava jelly out of strawberry guavas, it's a staple for breakfast, they eat it like applesauce is eaten. Jobs are hard to come by, & low paying, gas & energy costs outrageous, one of the highest in the nation. Agriculture is cut way back in the islands & not for a lack of workers. What's grown here is sold off island, & our food is shipped in from Thailand etc.

Land is cleared here before building, why is it necessary to wipe out strawberry guavas now? When property was originally sold here on the Big Island in the Puna district, only meager dirt roads were initially cleared & no flood control was planned or installed, it appears if these trees disappear suddenly, we may be facing major flooding.

Last but not least why would we want another foreign bug here to wreck Hawaii's delicate ecosystem. Haven't we learned anything from the plague of the coqui frog? What kind of character would want to kill all the strawberry guava trees? Needless to say, am frustrated & very upset! Citizens appear to have no rights or choices!

May 18, 2008
faith-based science
by: Anonymous


You obviously have no idea what you are talking about.
Scale insects are extremely species specific, and the Strawberry guava has very little in common with Ohia lehua, partcuularly as a food source for scale insects.

Biological pests are best controlled with biological solutions. Would you rather have people spray millions of gallons of toxic chemicals?

May 18, 2008
SAVE THE GUAVA
by: Syd Singer/ SAVE THE GUAVA

Thank you for discussing this vital issue. We have been receiving great public support to stop this insane release of an alien insect pest to attack the strawberry guava.

There are other alternatives to controlling the guava that can still allow the public to enjoy this superfruit resource. We need to weed the forests, but we also need to feed the people.

This is free food, and at a time of food shortages and high costs, this is not time to attack our wild food supply. Its impact on the food chain in the wild will be major.

The fruit also serves as an insect substrate to feed insectivorous birds, including native bird species.

What this will do to the environment is anyone's guess. And the government admits the insect can start attacking other species of plants, including related native species, such as the o`hia.

The DoA and DLNR should be protecting the environment from invasive insect pests, not introducing them.

Send your comments also to lyle.wong@hawaii.gov, and governor.lingle@hawaii.gov.

The phone number for SAVE THE GUAVA is 935-5563.


May 18, 2008
Thanks For the Big Island Alert
by: David

Awesome Danya

Did some more digging, and here are is another link to a article on this

Aloha David

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24624689/


Click here to add your own comments



footer for Big Island page